It’s that time of year again! Among the many highlights of the festive period is the surge in popularity of potluck-themed gatherings. Whether it’s Thanksgiving, Friendsgiving, or Christmas, rustling up a dish to bring to a potluck is always fun and exciting. Last year, we looked at some of the best main dishes with rice for our Potluck Recipes to Impress post. This year, we’re focusing on desserts. From creamy rice pudding to Hispanic-inspired horchata, we’ve got dessert recipes guaranteed to dazzle everyone in attendance. So, without further ado, let’s dive into the recipes!
What Makes Rice Desserts Perfect for Potluck Parties?
Rice-based desserts are the ultimate potluck crowd-pleaser! Ever wonder why? Here are some of the main advantages of preparing a rice dessert for your next potluck gathering.
- Make-Ahead Friendly: Most rice desserts, like rice pudding or rice-based cakes, can be prepared in advance and stored in the fridge, freeing up time on the day of the event.
- Easy to Transport: Rice desserts are usually stable and don’t spill easily, making them ideal for carrying to a friend’s or family gathering.
- Serves Many: Rice is naturally filling, so even a small batch can feed a crowd without breaking the budget.
- Versatile Flavors: You can easily customize rice desserts with spices, fruits, chocolate, or festive flavors like pumpkin or matcha to suit seasonal tastes.
- Appeals to Everyone: Rice desserts are generally mild and comforting, making them suitable for both kids and adults, including those with dietary restrictions, when made with alternatives like coconut milk.
Matcha Magic
If you’re lucky enough to have been invited to a potluck gathering, then you ought to return the favor. How? By preparing something special for everyone to enjoy. This Matcha Rice Pudding is both trendy and traditional, combining aromatic matcha powder with rice pudding made with fragrant Mahatma® Basmati Rice. Who knows? This dessert may end up being many people’s first experience of matcha!
Tried and True Holiday Season Favorite

Here’s one for the purists. Lovers of rice pudding and traditional festive treats will simply adore this Egg Nog Rice Pudding recipe. Don’t be put off by the number of ingredients needed to make this. They are all pantry staples, and our easy-to-follow recipe will guide you through the process so that your dessert is ready in 10 minutes. It’s the perfect dessert to make if you want something that’s both fun and festive.
Chef’s Tip: If you want to prepare an alcohol-free version of this, simply substitute rum for maple syrup.
Christmas Cake As You’ve Never Tasted It Before

Potluck gatherings are the perfect excuse to go out and discover a new recipe. Knowing that you’re learning something new adds to the excitement, so here’s one for the epicurious among you: this Christmas Cake Brown Rice Fritters. This novel take on traditional Christmas cake is sure to turn heads. These bite-sized brown rice treats are perfect for passing around on a platter. The best part? This dish puts a tropical twist on a seasonal classic, resulting in a dessert that’s both bold and beautiful.
Key Lime Pie with a Twist

The holiday season is all about making new friends and reconnecting with old ones. It’s this blend of celebrating past, present, and future that makes this time of year so special. In keeping with the spirit of festive fusion, here’s an American Classic given a Mahatma® Rice twist. This Key Lime Pie Rice Pudding will add a tropical twist to your celebration. Made with fluffy white rice, lime juice, and tartar sauce, it’s creamy and zesty in equal measure, making it the perfect dessert to round off any meal.
Horchata – A Light and Creamy Treat to Cap Off the Evening

One potential downside of potluck events is the possibility of overbooking. Everyone comes with the best of intentions and wants their culinary creativity to be the star of the show. However, if you’re looking for a delicious way to circumnavigate this dilemma, how about thinking outside the box by whipping up a refreshing batch of Homemade Mexican Horchata? A light and creamy drink may be just what everyone’s craving after a festive feast.
Potluck Success: Tips for Guests and Hosts
If you’re planning on hosting a potluck-themed gathering, here are a few important tips that you could keep in mind.
- Plan ahead – Use a signup sheet so dishes are balanced and no duplicates.
- Note dietary needs – Label dishes with allergens or restrictions.
- Bring ready-to-serve food – Avoid having to use the host’s oven.
- Include serving utensils – Don’t forget a spoon, tongs, or knife.
- Label your dish – Name and key ingredients help everyone out.
- Bring enough for 8–10 people – Ensures plenty to share.
- Use easy containers – Disposable or clearly labeled for easy cleanup.
- Organize the table – Group mains, sides, desserts, and drinks.
- Keep it social – Encourage mingling and share recipes afterward.
Festive Food that #Feelslikehome
Whether you’re attending or hosting, make the most of the occasion. Prepare food that feels and tastes like home. The festive spirit is all about sharing, and what better thing to share with the people you love than your creativity!
For more cooking tips and recipe ideas, drop by the Mahatma® Rice kitchen and see what we’ve been cooking.
